FTC fined a property giant Sh7 billion for hidden rental fees. Winter hunting is on.

In November 2026, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) announced that Progress Residential and its owner Pretium Partners will pay USD 49.75 million (approximately Sh7 billion) to settle charges of deceptive rental pricing practices. The company was accused of advertising false rental prices, then charging hidden fees once tenants were locked in, and improperly deducting security deposits.

The settlement is a rare win for renters, but it underscores a broader problem that winter makes worse: when housing becomes urgent, scammers move in. The FTC reported that between 2020 and June 2025, over 65,000 North Americans reported rental scams totaling USD 65 million in losses. About half of those scams started with a fake advertisement on Facebook.

How winter rental scams work

Rental scams exploit urgency. As temperatures drop and people scramble to secure housing before the cold arrives, scammers know you are more likely to skip verification steps and send money quickly.

The typical scam follows this pattern: A listing appears on Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, or Kijiji offering a rental well below market price. The images look professional. The landlord claims to be out of the country, on a mission trip, or otherwise unable to meet. They offer a lease agreement and property details. They ask for a deposit, first month's rent, or an application fee via bank transfer, wire, or another untraceable method. You send the money. Then, when you try to view the property or arrange move-in, the landlord stops responding. Or you arrive to find the property is already occupied, for sale, or does not match the listing at all.

In November 2026, a Nanaimo, British Columbia resident reported losing nearly CAD 4,000 in exactly this way. The victim saw a listing that included official-looking rental agreements and land title information. Several payments later, the victim tried to view the property and learned the truth from the actual homeowner: the rental ad was fake. The Nanaimo RCMP issued a formal warning to residents after the case.

The red flags everyone misses

Scammers are getting better. Many now use AI-generated photos, videos, and even voice recordings to appear legitimate. But several warning signs remain consistent and hard to fake.

  • Rent far below market.If the rent is 15 to 30 percent cheaper than similar properties in the area, ask why. Legitimate landlords price competitively, not drastically.
  • No in-person viewing.The landlord refuses to show the unit in person or via live video call. Common excuse: I am out of the country or I am too busy. Legitimate landlords accommodate viewings.
  • Pressure to decide now.The landlord claims many others are interested and you must decide today, or the listing will go. This is manufactured urgency.
  • Payment before a signed lease.Never send money without a written rental agreement signed by both you and the landlord. I will send it after payment means you will not see it.
  • Untraceable payment methods.Demands for wire transfer, Western Union, gift cards, or cryptocurrency are red flags. These methods cannot be reversed if fraud is discovered.
  • Generic contact email.Communication from Gmail or Hotmail instead of a property management company domain suggests the operation is not professional or official.

Steps to verify before you pay a single dollar

  1. Visit the property in person.If you are relocating and cannot arrive before move-in, have a trusted friend or family member do a live video walkthrough with you. Do not rely on photos or videos alone.
  2. Search the address online.Run the property address through Google, Craigslist, and Facebook Marketplace. If the same photos appear in multiple listings with different details, it is a scam.
  3. Reverse-image search the photos.Upload the property photos to Google Images. If the same images appear on other sites with different addresses, the listing is copied from somewhere else.
  4. Verify the landlord's identity.Ask for the landlord's name, phone number, and a copy of their ID. Search their name and phone online. Contact the local property registry or municipality to confirm who owns the property.
  5. Research market rent.Before you view a listing, know what similar properties in the area actually cost. If the listed rent is a shock, it probably is fraud.
  6. Pay by traceable method only.Use certified cheque, credit card, or bank-to-bank transfer (which can be reversed if needed). Get receipts for everything. Never pay in cash.

What you can do

  • Before responding to any rental listing, verify the property address online and check if it appears elsewhere with different details or prices.
  • Ask to meet the landlord in person or via video call from inside the property. Any refusal is a warning sign.
  • Get a written lease signed by both parties before paying anything. Read it carefully and confirm the property address, rent amount, and included amenities match the listing.
  • Know your provincial or territorial tenant rights before signing. Rules differ across Canada and the USA, and some jurisdictions ban certain fees or deposits that landlords might try to collect anyway.
  • Talk to other renters in the city on Diaspora Link about neighborhoods, rental costs, and landlords they trust. Real people in your community are your best protection.
  • If you suspect a rental scam, report it immediately to the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre (1-888-495-8501), local police, the RCMP, and the platform where you found the listing (Facebook, Kijiji, Craigslist). Do the same in the USA with the FTC and local police.

Why winter makes it worse

Winter rental scams spike because newcomers and students face real time pressure. You need shelter before the cold arrives. You may be job-hunting or settling in. You cannot easily return to view properties. Scammers know all of this. They list fake rentals at this exact moment, knowing desperation overrides caution.

The FTC settlement shows that even large, supposedly legitimate property managers get caught hiding fees. Imagine how easy it is for a lone scammer on Facebook. Winter is hunting season. Slow down, verify everything, and move into a home you have actually seen with your own eyes.

Sources

  1. Progress Residential and Pretium Partners Settle FTC Charges Over Deceptive Rental Pricing, Federal Trade Commission
  2. Nanaimo RCMP Police Warning - Rental Scam, Nanaimo RCMP
  3. San Francisco Supervisors Hold First Meeting to Prevent Rental Market Scams, KQED
rental-scamscanadausanewcomershousing-fraudftc-settlementwinter-2026facebook-marketplace

Educational content only. Articles in the Diaspora Link Journal are general information, not legal, financial or medical advice. Laws vary by location; consult a qualified professional about your situation.