Your landlord slides a clause into your lease: "Tenant is responsible for all repairs, including structural damage." You read it, nod, and sign. Six months later the pipes burst and your landlord says you have to fix them. You learn the clause is illegal in your province or state. By then you have paid CAD 3,000 or USD 2,500 to a plumber and lost your deposit.
This happens to diaspora renters every month. Landlords know newcomers are less likely to contest illegal terms. Here are the clauses that never hold up in court, and what you can do if you signed one.
Structural repairs are always the landlord's job
Your lease cannot require you to pay for:
- Roof leaks or damage
- Foundation cracks or water seepage
- Broken pipes or plumbing inside walls
- Electrical system failures
- Windows that won't close or are cracked
- Walls that are deteriorating or moldy
- HVAC systems (heating, cooling, air conditioning)
These arestructural repairs. The landlord owns the building. The law makes the landlord responsible for keeping it safe and habitable. No clause can override that.
What you are responsible for
You pay for damage you cause:
- Broken windows from your accident (not from age)
- Stains or damage from your negligence
- Lost or broken keys you were given
- Holes you put in walls (normal wear and tear does not count)
The key legal phrase is "normal wear and tear." Carpets that fade, paint that chips from age, appliances that stop working after years, these are normal. You do not pay for them. The landlord does.
If your lease says otherwise, it is not enforceable
In Canada and the USA, landlord-tenant law overrides any lease clause that tries to shift structural maintenance to the tenant. If your landlord tells you to pay, you have options:
- Write it down:Tell the landlord in writing that the clause is illegal and you will not pay. Keep a copy.
- Report it:Contact your provincial (Canada) or state (USA) housing authority or tenant board. Many have online complaint forms.
- Withhold rent (carefully):Some provinces and states allow you to set aside rent in an escrow account if the landlord fails to make required repairs. This is legal only in some jurisdictions, so check first. Talk to a tenant advocate before you do this.
- Get help:Tenant advocacy groups and legal clinics in your city can review your lease for free and advise you. Search "[your city] tenant rights clinic" or "[your province/state] legal aid".
Red flags that your lease is illegal
Watch for these phrases when you sign:
- "No repairs required by landlord"
- "Tenant accepts the apartment 'as is' with no repairs"
- "Landlord is not responsible for damage of any kind"
- "All repairs are the tenant's responsibility"
- "Tenant waives the right to withhold rent for non-repairs"
If you see any of these, cross them out, initial the change, have the landlord initial it, and keep a photo. Or refuse to sign and walk away. A landlord who insists on illegal terms will not respect you later.
What you can do now
- Read your lease again:Look for any clause that says you must repair the building or that the landlord has no repair duties. Write down the exact words.
- Contact a tenant clinic:Most Canadian provinces and US states have free or low-cost legal help for renters. Find yours at http://www.acto.ca (Ontario), or search "[your state] legal aid tenant" for USA options.
- Document everything:Take photos and videos of any disrepair. Write dates and what happened. Send the landlord written requests for repairs (email works). Keep copies of everything.
- Know your rights in your jurisdiction:Tenant rights vary by province and state. Ontario and BC have strong tenant protections. Some US states (like California) are strict; others give landlords more power. Know yours before you rent.
- Connect with other renters in the Diaspora Link community for your city:Other newcomers have been through this. Ask them what landlords to avoid and what clinics helped them.
You deserve a safe home. The law backs you up. Use it.
What illegal clauses have you seen in a lease? Tell us in your city's group on Diaspora Link, and help other renters avoid them.
Sources
- Residential Tenancies Act, Ontario, Government of Ontario
- Tenant Rights and Responsibilities, Government of British Columbia
Educational content only. Articles in the Diaspora Link Journal are general information, not legal, financial or medical advice. Laws vary by location; consult a qualified professional about your situation.