A Nanaimo resident believed they had found a legitimate online listing for rental housing. The advertisement looked real. The rental agreement seemed properly formatted. The seller even provided land title information. So the victim sent money through online banking, believing it was a deposit.
Only when the person tried to view the property and met the homeowner did the fraud become clear. The homeowner said the person they had been negotiating with was not authorized to rent out the home.
How the scam worked
According to RCMP, the fraudster responded to the online rental search and posed as the landlord. They provided a rental agreement and documentation that appeared to prove they owned or managed the property. This created the illusion of legitimacy. The victim, wanting to secure housing quickly, sent money before conducting further verification.
The Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre has reported a sharp rise in rental scams since 2023, with millions of dollars lost to fake listings and hijacked property photos. Toronto, Vancouver, and Calgary are particularly affected because tight housing markets pressure renters to move quickly without doing full due diligence.
"Finding affordable housing can be stressful and scammers often take advantage of people who feel pressured to secure a place to live quickly," said Nanaimo RCMP operations officer Inspector Donovan Tait. "Taking a few extra steps to verify a rental listing and the identity of the landlord can help prevent a significant financial loss."
The same property, scammed twice
What makes this case particularly troubling is that the same Nanaimo property information has been used in multiple scam attempts. Fraudsters reuse successful schemes. Once they know which listings attract renters, they exploit them repeatedly.
This is a pattern across Canada. Scammers save property details, photos, and addresses that get views and clicks, then cycle through them with different fake landlord identities. A property that was legitimately advertised months ago can become a scam vehicle six times over.
Common rental scam tactics in Canada
- Hijacked listings:Real properties with real photos, but the advertiser has no authority to rent them.
- Absent landlord:Claims to be out of the country for work (military, oil rig, missionary) and cannot meet in person.
- Bait and switch:A unit is shown during viewing, then a different unit (or no unit) is what the lease describes.
- Pressure to act:"Someone else is interested." "Price increases tomorrow." "I can only hold it 24 hours."
- Application or holding fees:Charged $50 to $200 before any lease is signed or property viewed.
- Lease-only scams:A well-formatted lease is sent, first and last month's rent requested, then the scammer disappears before the renter can take occupancy.
- Below-market rent:A property 20 to 40 percent cheaper than comparable units in the neighbourhood.
- Untraceable payment:Cash, wire transfer, e-transfer to a personal account, or cryptocurrency demanded.
What to verify before you pay anything
- Always view the property in person or via live video.If the landlord claims to be out of the country or unable to meet, be very suspicious. Legitimate landlords meet prospective tenants.
- Research the address online.Conduct a reverse image search on the photos. If those same photos appear on other listing sites with different prices or addresses, it is a scam.
- Check for duplicate listings.Search the property address across multiple platforms (Craigslist, Kijiji, Facebook Marketplace, Rent.com). Multiple identical ads for the same property at different prices is a major red flag.
- Verify landlord ownership.For a new development, contact the builder directly and confirm the landlord is authorized to rent. For existing rentals, conduct a property title search at the provincial land registry to confirm who owns it.
- Demand a written lease agreement.Any legitimate landlord provides a signed lease before rent or deposits change hands. The lease should include names, addresses, rent amount, lease dates, and terms.
- Never send money before signing.Not before viewing, not before a lease is signed, not for "application fees" or "holding fees". Legitimate landlords take deposits only after a signed lease.
- Use traceable payment methods.Credit cards and bank transfers leave a paper trail. Cash, Western Union, MoneyGram, and e-transfer to personal accounts do not. If a landlord insists on untraceable payment, the deal is not legitimate.
- Speak with current tenants.If the property is occupied, try to speak with existing renters (away from the landlord) about their experience. What do they pay. How responsive is the landlord to repairs. Do they trust them.
- Do not share sensitive information.Landlords can ask for proof of income but should not request your Social Insurance Number, credit card, or unredacted bank statements. If they do, provide a redacted version or your own credit report instead.
- Be wary of high-pressure language."Limited time." "Act fast." "Others are viewing today." These create urgency to prevent you from verifying information.
If you think you are being scammed
Stop all payments immediately. Report the suspected fraud to your local police force, your bank, and the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre. Document all communications and payment records. These become evidence if you pursue recovery or legal action.
Before you sign a lease or send a deposit, verify the landlord's identity and the property's ownership. This step takes days but can save thousands. See rental opportunities and connect with renters who can share advice about neighbourhoods and landlords in your city on Diaspora Link.
Do you rent or own. What scams have you encountered. Tell us in your city's group on Diaspora Link.
Sources
- Nanaimo renters warned to look out for 'rental scam' that cost resident $4K, Cowichan Valley Now
- Rental scams | Royal Canadian Mounted Police, Royal Canadian Mounted Police
- Common rental scams and how to avoid them, TenantPay
Educational content only. Articles in the Diaspora Link Journal are general information, not legal, financial or medical advice. Laws vary by location; consult a qualified professional about your situation.