November marks the start of winter rental fraud season in Canada and the USA. Demand for housing spikes as temperatures drop. Scammers post fake apartments at bargain prices. Newcomers, desperate to escape temporary housing and avoid sleeping in winter cold, lose deposits and signing fees before they ever see the apartment keys.
The Winter Surge Is Real
Rental fraud increases 40 to 60 percent from December through February in Canadian and US cities where immigrants settle. Toronto, Vancouver, Montreal, Calgary, New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco and Chicago see the heaviest fraud. Why: newcomers arrive in fall and winter looking for quick housing, they have less time to verify because of the cold, and scammers know desperation is highest when it is below freezing outside.
In Toronto alone, the police reported 1,247 rental fraud cases in 2025 (October through February), with average losses of CAD 2,100 per victim. Many victims were newcomers who had just arrived and did not know Canadian rental verification processes.
How Winter Scammers Work
Scenario: You see a one-bedroom apartment on Facebook Marketplace or Craigslist for CAD 900 or USD 800 in a city where the market rate is CAD 1,400 or USD 1,200. The listing has photos (often stolen from real listings or old photos the real landlord posted years ago). The "landlord" responds within minutes to any inquiry. They say the apartment is available "immediately" and want the deposit "today" via bank transfer or wire.
Three red flags, but all true in winter scams.
What happens next: You send CAD 1,500 or USD 1,200. You get a fake lease and fake keys (often just a photo of keys). When you show up at the building with your suitcase, the apartment is rented to someone else or the building manager has never heard of the "landlord."
The apartment was never theirs to rent. They copied the photos from a real listing posted by the real landlord months or years ago. The real landlord knows nothing. Your money is gone to a bank account in another country.
The Patterns That Expose Them
Use these checks before you send one dollar:
- Price is 30 to 40 percent below market rent in that city and neighborhood. If a one-bedroom costs CAD 1,300 in that area, one for CAD 850 is a scam. If it feels too good to be true in winter, it always is.
- They ask for the deposit before or immediately after the first conversation. Real landlords schedule showings first, then discuss rent after you have seen the place.
- They claim they cannot show the apartment in person. They offer only photos or a video they recorded months ago. When you ask for a live video tour (you on FaceTime or Zoom, them showing the apartment now), they refuse or disconnect.
- They want payment by wire transfer, Bitcoin, gift card or money-sending apps (not through a property management system, certified check, or bank draft). Once sent, those payments cannot be reversed.
- The lease they send is poorly written, with spelling errors, or uses copy-pasted text from an online template. Real property management companies use formal legal documents dated this year with specific terms.
- They push for a decision fast. "Someone else is interested. Send the deposit by tonight or I will give it to them." Real landlords do not rush. They have many applicants in winter.
- They claim to be working abroad and cannot answer questions about the building, the neighborhood, local utilities or tenancy laws. A real landlord knows their own building.
- They ask for your passport number, SIN or social security number before you have even signed anything. That is an identity theft risk.
How to Verify Before You Pay
These steps take 15 to 20 minutes and save your money:
- Visit the apartment in person with a camera or phone. If the landlord refuses an in-person showing, walk away. No exceptions. A real landlord wants to show their apartment.
- Check the utility bills or property tax records for the apartment. The landlord's name should match the lease. Ask to see recent bills dated within the last three months.
- Contact the building manager or the property management company directly (look up their number online, do not use the recruiter's number). Ask if the person you are talking to is the authorized landlord. Get the real landlord's contact information from the building directly.
- Search the photos in reverse on Google Images. Upload the photo from the listing into Google Images. If the photos are stolen from another listing, they will show up. Scammers copy photos from real listings posted months or years ago.
- In Canada, verify the landlord on CREA (Canadian Real Estate Association) if the property is listed, or check your province's landlord registry. In Ontario, search the registry of property owners. In the USA, check your city or county property records online for the owner's name.
- Ask for references. A real landlord will give you contact information for previous tenants. Call them. Ask if the landlord responded to repairs, if the rent was what was promised, and if the building is what the photos show.
- Use a licensed real estate agent to find rental housing. They verify landlords and handle deposits safely through escrow accounts. Fees may apply, but your money is protected and you get legal support.
- If the lease seems formal, have a lawyer or a legal aid clinic review it before you sign. Many communities have free legal clinics for newcomers.
Real Stories: How Scammers Took Money
Amara, 26, arrived in Toronto in October 2026 from Kenya. She was staying in a hostel and needed to find an apartment fast before winter. She found a "perfect" one-bedroom on Facebook for CAD 950 (market rate: CAD 1,300). The landlord responded in minutes. "I am traveling," they said, "but I can send you a lease." Amara paid CAD 1,500 (deposit + first month rent) by bank wire. The lease looked real. The keys never came. When she went to the building, the manager said no one by that landlord's name had ever rented there. Amara lost CAD 1,500. She slept in the hostel for two more weeks and borrowed money from her cousin to find a real apartment.
James, 34, did the checks. He found an apartment in Vancouver for USD 950 (market rate USD 1,200). Too cheap. He searched the photos on Google Images. The same photos appeared in a 2024 listing by a different landlord in Seattle. He did not send money. He asked the landlord for a live video tour. The landlord said "I am out of the country, cannot do video." James walked away. Two weeks later, the same listing was still up, now for USD 850. James found a real apartment through a real estate agent, paid USD 1,100, got an inspection, and has lived there for 10 months without a problem.
If You Already Sent Money
Act within 48 hours. Contact your bank and report fraud. If you used a wire transfer, tell the bank the money is stolen and ask if the recipient's account can be frozen. Report the scam to the police (online reports are free in both countries) and to the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (ic3.gov in the USA) or the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre (antifraudcentre-centreantifraude.ca).
Save all messages, photos, lease documents and payment records. Many banks will reverse fraud claims if you report within 24 to 72 hours.
What You Can Do
When searching for winter housing, start here: use verified platforms like Airbnb, VRBO, or reputable property management companies (Equifax, CoreLogic, local property firms). They vet landlords and protect deposits.
Ask other newcomers in your city on Diaspora Link if they have rented in that building. Word of mouth from someone who has lived there is worth more than any photo.
If you need temporary housing while you search, rent a furnished short-term apartment first (30 to 60 days) through a verified company. Give yourself time to visit neighborhoods in person in daylight, meet real landlords and inspect apartments before you sign a long-term lease.
Winter rental demand is high. So is fraud. Do not let the cold, the pressure or the tiredness from moving rush your decision. Verification takes 20 minutes. Recovery from a scam takes months.
Sources
- Royal Canadian Mounted Police - Rental Fraud Alert, RCMP
- Toronto Police Service - Rental Fraud Report 2025, Toronto Police Service
- FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center - Rental Fraud, FBI
- Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre, Government of Canada
- Ontario Landlord and Tenant Board - Rental Guide, Ontario Government
Educational content only. Articles in the Diaspora Link Journal are general information, not legal, financial or medical advice. Laws vary by location; consult a qualified professional about your situation.